
Separation of powers and constitutions
Power that can do anything will sooner or later abuse it. That is why states split it among several institutions that keep an eye on each other.
Three branches
The idea of the separation of powers is most closely linked to the French thinker Montesquieu and his work The Spirit of the Laws from 1748. The English philosopher John Locke had put forward similar ideas earlier. The point is that no single person or institution should hold all three jobs of the state.
The legislative branch (parliament) passes laws and the budget. The executive branch (government, president, civil service) puts laws into practice and runs the state day to day. The judicial branch (the courts) settles disputes and decides whether the law has been broken.
In practice the lines are blurred. In parliamentary systems ministers usually sit in parliament, so people speak of a fusion of legislative and executive power. Judicial independence, however, remains a foundation of nearly every democracy.
The constitution: the highest law
A constitution sets out how the state works: which bodies it has, how they are chosen, what those in power may do and what rights citizens have. Other laws must be consistent with it.
The oldest written national constitution still in force is the United States Constitution of 1787. Poland’s Constitution of 3 May 1791 is regarded as the first modern constitution in Europe and the second in the world. Poland’s current constitution was adopted in 1997 and approved by referendum. Germany’s Basic Law (Grundgesetz) has been in force since 1949.
Constitutions are harder to change than ordinary laws. In the US an amendment needs two-thirds of both houses of Congress and ratification by three-quarters of the states, which is why only 27 amendments have been adopted since 1787. In Poland it takes two-thirds of the Sejm and an absolute majority in the Senate. In Germany it takes two-thirds of both the Bundestag and the Bundesrat, and some principles, such as human dignity and federalism, cannot be changed at all (the eternity clause, Article 79(3)).
Checks and balances
Separation alone is not enough. Each branch needs tools to restrain the others. That is the system of checks and balances.
A few examples. The US president can veto a bill, but Congress can override the veto with a two-thirds vote in both houses. The president nominates Supreme Court justices, but the Senate confirms them. The House of Representatives can impeach the president by a simple majority, and the Senate can remove the president with a two-thirds vote. In Poland the president can veto a bill, and the Sejm can override it with a three-fifths majority.
The oldest check of all, though, is the budget: a government cannot spend money parliament has not approved. On top of that come committees of inquiry, parliamentary questions, independent audit offices and a free press.
Constitutional courts and judicial review
Who decides whether a law complies with the constitution? There are two main models of judicial review.
In the American model any court can do it in the course of a concrete case, and the Supreme Court has the last word. The principle was established by the 1803 case Marbury v. Madison, even though the US Constitution itself says little about it directly.
In the European model there is a separate constitutional court. The first ones were set up under the 1920 constitutions of Czechoslovakia and Austria, and the Austrian court became the model for Europe. Germany’s Federal Constitutional Court in Karlsruhe has 16 judges elected for a single 12-year term by a two-thirds majority, half by the Bundestag and half by the Bundesrat. Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal has 15 judges elected by the Sejm for nine years. Since 2010 France’s Constitutional Council has been able to review laws already in force when a party to a court case raises the question.
Supporters of strong constitutional courts say they protect minorities and citizens from a passing majority. Critics note that unelected judges can overturn decisions of elected parliaments, and the way judges are appointed easily becomes a political battleground. Many countries argue over who should choose judges and how.
Judicial independence is usually protected by concrete guarantees: judges cannot be removed from office except in exceptional cases set out in law, they serve long terms without re-election, their pay cannot be cut over an unwelcome ruling, and they may not belong to a party. US Supreme Court justices serve for life. The Council of Europe and its Venice Commission have long set out standards meant to ensure that courts decide according to the law, not according to what the government of the day expects.
The United Kingdom: an uncodified constitution
The United Kingdom has no single document called a constitution. Its system is built from major statutes (from Magna Carta in 1215 through the Bill of Rights of 1689 to the Human Rights Act 1998), court rulings and conventions, unwritten practices everyone follows. New Zealand is similar, and Israel has a set of Basic Laws instead of a constitution.
The key principle is parliamentary sovereignty: parliament can pass or change any law by a simple majority. The UK Supreme Court has existed since 2009, but it cannot strike down an Act of Parliament. It can only declare a law incompatible with the rights in the European Convention on Human Rights, and it is up to politicians to change it.
Supporters value the flexibility and the fact that elected representatives have the final say. Critics argue that rights then depend on the goodwill of a parliamentary majority and on traditions that can be ignored.
Key terms
- Separation of powers
- Splitting power into legislative, executive and judicial branches so none holds total control.
- Checks and balances
- Tools one branch uses to restrain another, such as vetoes, confirmations and control of the budget.
- Judicial review
- A court’s power to decide whether a law or government action complies with the constitution.
- Constitutional court
- A separate court that reviews whether laws comply with the constitution (e.g. Karlsruhe).
- Uncodified constitution
- A system based on many statutes, rulings and conventions rather than one document (e.g. the UK).
- Parliamentary sovereignty
- The principle that parliament can make or change any law and no court can strike its Acts down.
How it works in Politicus
In the Power tab you will find the Other power centers panel. In most countries the court tile has three modes: independent, mixed and captured (in the US: Pack the court, Balanced bench and Independent judiciary). Changing it costs political capital and is possible once every 12 months. Capturing the court burns 12 prestige and weakens the brake on corruption. Restoring independence gives +4 prestige. In the US, the Supreme Court can strike down some acts of constitutional weight, with the odds depending on the balance of the court. Those acts also cost 25% more political capital because of the filibuster. In Poland a separate president can veto your law: the chance is 25, 33 or 50% depending on difficulty, unless the president is your ally. Overriding the veto costs 20 PC and needs a 3/5 vote in the Sejm. The Constitution tile lets you change six constitutional frameworks, from the form of government to the right to bear arms. In the UK, the Monarch and House of Lords tiles take the place of a president. Separation of powers in practice: every time you are right, someone else gets to check.
Sources
- Encyclopaedia Britannica — Separation of powers
- U.S. National Archives — The Constitution of the United States
- Konstytucja Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej (1997) — Sejm RP
- Basic Law for the Federal Republic of Germany — Federal Ministry of Justice
- Bundesverfassungsgericht — The Court: Organisation and judges
- Council of Europe, Venice Commission — Rule of Law Checklist (2016)
- UK Parliament — The UK constitution


