
Electoral systems: how votes become seats
The same set of votes can produce a completely different parliament. It all depends on the rules used to count them.
Why the rules matter
Voters cast votes, but parliaments are made of seats. Between the two sits the electoral system: a set of rules that says how the country is divided into districts, how many members each district elects, and which method turns votes into seats.
These rules are not just technical. They decide how many parties get into parliament, whether one party can win a majority on its own or coalitions become necessary, and how closely a member is tied to a particular place. That is why changing the electoral law is often one of the fiercest debates in politics.
Majoritarian systems: winner takes the seat
The simplest version is single-member districts with the first past the post (FPTP) rule. Each district elects one member, and the seat goes to the candidate with the most votes, even without a majority. That is how the UK House of Commons (650 constituencies), the US House of Representatives and the Canadian House of Commons are elected. Poland has used the same method for its 100 senators since 2011.
The effects can be striking. In the 2024 UK general election the winning party took about 34% of the vote and 411 of 650 seats, or 63% (House of Commons Library, 2024). In 2015 another party won 12.6% of the vote but a single seat, because its voters were spread thinly across the country.
The two-round system softens the problem of winning with little support. For the French National Assembly (577 members), a candidate wins in the first round with an absolute majority of valid votes, provided that this also equals at least 25% of registered voters. Otherwise, candidates backed by at least 12.5% of registered voters go through to a second round (if fewer than two clear that bar, the top two do). Many countries, including Poland and France, also elect their presidents in two rounds.
A third option is preferential voting, used for the lower house in Australia: voters rank the candidates, and the votes of eliminated candidates pass to the next preference until someone has more than 50%.
Proportional systems: D’Hondt and Sainte-Laguë
In a proportional system districts elect several members, and parties put forward lists of candidates. The aim is for each party’s share of seats to match its share of votes as closely as possible. Poland’s Sejm has 460 members elected in 41 districts, with seats shared out by the D’Hondt method (Electoral Code). Spain, Portugal and the Netherlands use the same method.
D’Hondt works like this: each party’s votes are divided by 1, 2, 3, 4… and the seats go to the largest results. Example: a district has 4 seats, party A has 10,000 votes, B has 8,000 and C has 3,000. The largest quotients are 10,000 (A), 8,000 (B), 5,000 (A) and 4,000 (B). Result: A gets 2 seats, B gets 2, and C gets none.
The Sainte-Laguë method divides by 1, 3, 5, 7… In the same example the quotients are 10,000 (A), 8,000 (B), 3,333 (A) and 3,000 (C), so the split is 2–1–1 and the small party wins a seat too. As a rule, D’Hondt slightly favours large parties, while Sainte-Laguë comes closer to exact proportionality. Germany, New Zealand, Sweden and Norway use versions of Sainte-Laguë.
District size matters a lot as well. The fewer seats a district has, the harder it is for small parties, even under a formally proportional system.
FPTP or proportional: a debate about values
No system is best at everything. Each one trades off goals that are hard to combine.
Supporters of single-member districts say voters know who their representative is and can hold that person to account. The system usually gives one party a majority, so governments are stable and clearly responsible, and it is harder for fringe groups to enter parliament.
Critics reply that many votes are wasted because they never turn into a seat, and a party backed by a minority of voters can govern alone. Smaller parties are under-represented, and people sometimes vote tactically rather than for the party they actually prefer. Political scientists also describe a tendency for FPTP to produce two-party systems (known as Duverger’s law).
Supporters of proportional representation stress that parliament mirrors society and almost every vote counts. Critics point out that coalitions are needed more often, their shape is decided by party leaders after the election, and negotiations can drag on. Below you can test how the same votes look under both systems.
Mixed systems: Germany and New Zealand
Many countries combine the two approaches. Under mixed-member proportional representation (MMP), voters have two votes: one for a candidate in a single-member district and one for a party list. The list vote decides each party’s overall share of seats, and district winners are counted within that share.
This is how the Bundestag works. After a 2023 reform it has a fixed 630 seats and 299 constituencies. The new rule is that a constituency winner only takes the seat if it is covered by the party’s list-vote result. New Zealand switched to MMP after a 1993 referendum and first voted that way in 1996, having used British-style FPTP before.
There is also the parallel system, where some members are elected in districts and some from lists, but the two pools are counted separately, so the result is less proportional. Japan uses this model, with 289 of its 465 members elected in single-member districts. South Korea has a similar set-up: in 2024, 254 of its 300 members were elected in districts, and the list seats only partly even out the result.
Electoral thresholds
An electoral threshold is the minimum result a party needs to take part in the share-out of seats at all. In Poland it is 5% for parties and 8% for electoral coalitions, with national-minority committees exempt. In Germany a party enters the Bundestag with 5% of the vote or by winning three constituencies (the 2023 reform scrapped this second route, but in 2024 the Federal Constitutional Court kept it in place). New Zealand uses 5% or one electorate seat, Israel 3.25%, and Turkey 7% since 2022 (10% before). The Netherlands has no formal threshold: enough votes for one of 150 seats is enough.
Supporters of thresholds say they protect parliament from fragmentation and make it easier to form governments. Critics note that votes for parties just below the line end up represented by no one, and a high threshold can artificially boost the largest parties.
Choosing an electoral system always means balancing representativeness, simplicity, stable government and the link between members and voters. Every country sets those sliders differently.
Key terms
- First past the post (FPTP)
- Each district elects one member; the candidate with the most votes wins, even without a majority.
- Proportional representation
- Seats are shared among party lists so that they match each party’s share of the vote.
- D’Hondt method
- A way to convert votes into seats by dividing by 1, 2, 3…; it slightly favours large parties.
- Electoral threshold
- The minimum share of the vote a party needs to take part in the share-out of seats.
- Mixed-member proportional (MMP)
- Two votes, one for a district candidate and one for a list; the list vote decides each party’s total seats.
How it works in Politicus
In Politicus the general election comes down to one number: government support, meaning your party’s approval plus your coalition partner’s share and a bonus for kept promises. Reach 50% and you stay in office. The bars on election night show the vote split, but the game deliberately simplifies the seat arithmetic, which is exactly why there is a widget above. Country rules still matter. In Poland and Germany the poll chart shows a 5% threshold, and your advisor warns you when your party gets close to the line. The UK (FPTP) and Australia (preferential voting) have no threshold. Argentina has a real ballotage: you win in round one with 45%, or 40% with a 10-point lead. Otherwise the top two from round one go to a run-off (finish third and you are out), and the other parties’ votes transfer by ideological distance. In the US, a campaign HQ tile projects the 538 electoral votes (270 to win). Arithmetic doesn’t vote, but it always wins.
Sources
- International IDEA — Electoral System Design: The New International IDEA Handbook
- House of Commons Library — General election 2024 results (CBP-10009)
- Kodeks wyborczy (Dz.U. 2011 nr 21 poz. 112) — ISAP Sejm
- Die Bundeswahlleiterin — Bundestag electoral system
- Electoral Commission New Zealand — What is MMP?
- Inter-Parliamentary Union — Parline database



