Politicus Lab · 7 min read

Healthcare systems: who pays for treatment

Every wealthy country looks after its citizens’ health, but each does it differently. The differences come down to three questions: who pays, who treats, and who decides.

Why health is an unusual market

We buy bread every day and know what it costs. Treatment is different: nobody knows when they will fall ill, and a single operation can cost more than a year’s salary. That is why almost every country pools risk: many people pay regularly into a shared fund, and that fund pays for the care of whoever happens to need it.

Countries differ in how they built that pool. The money can come from taxes, from contributions taken out of wages, or from private insurance policies. Hospitals and clinics can be state-owned, private or non-profit. Economists and journalists often describe this with four models. In practice nearly every country mixes several of them, but the models help explain where the differences come from.

The Beveridge model: care paid for by taxes

The name comes from a 1942 British report that proposed a universal system of social security. It led to the creation of Britain’s NHS (National Health Service) in 1948. In this model healthcare is funded from general taxation, and the state is both the payer and the main owner of hospitals. Patients usually pay nothing at the point of use.

Spain, Italy, the Nordic countries and New Zealand work along similar lines, each with its own details. Supporters stress that care is available to everyone regardless of job or income, and that a single payer finds it easier to control costs. Critics point out that quality depends on how much money the political budget provides, and that underfunding shows up as longer waits for doctors and operations.

The Bismarck model: sickness funds and contributions

The oldest model comes from Germany, which introduced compulsory sickness insurance for workers in 1883. Here the foundation is contributions taken from wages and paid by both employee and employer into sickness funds. The funds pay for treatment, while hospitals and doctors are often private or non-profit. In Germany people above a certain income can choose private insurance instead of a public fund.

Versions of this model run in France (public health insurance topped up with supplementary policies), Belgium and Japan. Since 2006 the Netherlands, and since 1996 Switzerland, have used a variant in which everyone must buy basic insurance from a private insurer operating under strict state rules.

Poland combines features of several models. The money comes mainly from a health contribution (9% of the base for employees), but since 2003 it has gone to a single public payer, the National Health Fund (NFZ). Supporters of contribution-based systems say that keeping health money separate from the rest of the budget brings stability, and that competition between funds or hospitals improves service. Critics point to higher administrative costs and argue that wage contributions put an extra burden on jobs.

National health insurance: one public payer

The third model combines elements of the first two. Doctors and hospitals often work privately, but the bills are paid by a single public insurer, funded by taxes or contributions. Canada is the classic example: the first province, Saskatchewan, introduced public insurance for doctors’ services in 1962, and the national rules are set by the Canada Health Act of 1984. Each province runs its own plan, and the federal government contributes money as long as the plans meet common conditions.

South Korea extended health insurance to its whole population in 1989 and has had one national insurer since 2000. Taiwan built a similar system in 1995. Since 1984 Australia has had a public Medicare scheme funded by taxes and a dedicated levy, alongside private insurance supported by a rebate.

Supporters stress that one large payer has strong bargaining power over the prices of drugs and services, and that there is less paperwork. Critics point to waiting lists for specialists (a frequent subject of debate in Canada) and to services such as prescription drugs or dentistry that are partly left outside the system or require co-payments.

The market model and the US case

In the fourth model patients pay for themselves, out of pocket or through a private policy. In its pure form it exists mainly in poorer countries, where there is simply no shared pool. Among wealthy nations the most market-based system belongs to the United States, though it too is a mixture.

Most Americans are insured through an employer: 53.7% of the population in 2023. The government funds two large programmes dating from 1965: Medicare for people aged 65 and over, and Medicaid for people on low incomes. The Affordable Care Act (ACA) of 2010 created subsidised insurance marketplaces. According to the US Census Bureau, 8.0% of people, about 26.4 million, were uninsured for the whole of 2023.

Supporters of market solutions say competition brings choice, short waits and incentives to innovate, and that the US leads the world in research on new medicines. Critics point out that the system is the most expensive in the world, coverage often depends on having a job, and large bills can push families into debt. The argument over how much government belongs in American healthcare has gone on for decades.

Costs and outcomes: what the numbers say

According to the OECD, its member countries spent an average of 9.3% of GDP on health in 2024. The US spent 17.2%, Germany 12.3%, France 11.5%, Canada 11.3%, the United Kingdom 11.1%, Japan 10.6%, Australia 10.3%, South Korea 8.4% and Poland 8.1%. Per person, the US spent about $14,900 (adjusted for purchasing power), against an OECD average of about $6,000 and about $4,300 in Poland (provisional figures).

Life expectancy in 2023 averaged 81.1 years across the OECD: 84.1 in Japan, 83.5 in South Korea, 83.0 in Australia and France, 81.7 in Canada, 81.1 in Germany, 81.0 in the United Kingdom, and 78.4 in both the US and Poland.

It is tempting to declare a winner from these figures, but care is needed. Life expectancy depends not only on hospitals but also on diet, smoking, accidents, income and lifestyle. The OECD itself notes that higher spending tends to go with better results but does not guarantee them. How efficiently the money is spent matters too.

Shared challenges

Whatever the model, every system faces similar problems. Populations are ageing, new drugs and technologies keep getting more expensive, and there are not enough doctors and nurses. The OECD estimates that health already takes about 15% of government spending, and that public spending on it could rise by an average of 1.5 percentage points of GDP by 2045.

The World Health Organization (WHO) promotes the goal of universal health coverage: everyone should be able to get the care they need without the risk of financial ruin. Countries agree on the goal and argue about the route: how much should come from taxpayers, patients and employers, and what role the state and the market should play.

Key terms

Risk pooling
Many people pay into a shared fund that covers the treatment of those who fall ill.
Single payer
A system in which one public body pays the bills for care, such as Poland’s NFZ or Canada’s provincial plans.
Sickness fund
An insurance body in the Bismarck model that collects contributions and pays for its members’ care.
Co-payment
The part of the cost of care or medicine that a patient pays out of pocket despite being insured.
Universal health coverage
A WHO goal: everyone can get the care they need without risking financial ruin.

How it works in Politicus

In every Politicus country healthcare has its own ministry, and its laws reflect local realities. In Poland you set the level of NFZ funding (from no public care to generous funding) and whether private insurance is banned, allowed or promoted. In the UK you decide the NHS budget and waiting times, in Germany sickness fund contributions, in Australia the Medicare levy and bulk billing, in Canada the provincial health transfer and pharmacare, in South Korea the health insurance levy and medical school quotas, and in South Africa the rollout of National Health Insurance (NHI). In the US, Health & Human Services lets you choose anything from repealing the ACA to a public option. Health funding makes up a quarter of the citizens’ welfare score on the Statistics tab. More generous funding pleases retirees and public sector workers, but it costs money and in Poland it pushes corruption up. More money means more opportunities. A hospital takes years to build, and a campaign promise takes seconds.

Sources

Updated 2026-11

The game

Now run a country yourself

Politicus is a political simulation for iPhone and iPad: real countries, real budgets, coalitions and election nights. Your first term is free.