
Public debt and the deficit
Almost every country in the world is in debt, some of them deeply. What is the difference between a deficit and debt, how much debt is too much, and what happens when markets stop trusting a government?
A deficit is not debt
These two words are often confused. A deficit is the gap in a single year: the state spent more than it collected in taxes and other income. Public debt is the total of all past borrowing that has not yet been repaid. The deficit is the water flowing into the bathtub this year; the debt is all the water already in it.
If a state runs a deficit every year, its debt grows. Even shrinking the deficit does not reduce the debt, it only slows its growth. For the debt itself to fall, the state needs a surplus: income higher than spending. That is rare: in recent decades many rich countries ran surpluses only in occasional years.
Why do states borrow?
A state borrows mainly by selling bonds: securities in which it promises to repay the money after several or even dozens of years and usually to pay interest every year. They are bought by banks, pension funds, insurers, foreign central banks and often by ordinary citizens too, for example through savings bonds.
The reasons vary. Borrowing spreads the cost of big investments, such as roads or power plants, across the generations who will use them. It helps a country get through a crisis: in a recession tax revenue falls while spending on benefits rises, so a deficit appears almost automatically. Wars, pandemics and bank rescues are the classic moments when debt jumps. And sometimes it is simply easier for governments to promise new spending than to raise taxes.
How much is too much?
The amount of debt on its own says little, because big economies have big debts. That is why debt is compared to GDP, the value of everything a country produces in a year. According to IMF and Eurostat figures for 2023, it stood at roughly 240% in Japan, over 160% in Greece, about 135% in Italy, about 120% in the US, about 110% in France, about 63% in Germany, about 50% in Poland and only about 20% in Estonia.
There is no single safe limit. Japan has a huge debt, but most of it is held by domestic institutions, including its central bank, and it is in its own currency. Developing countries have run into trouble at far lower levels, especially when they borrowed in foreign currency: when their own currency fell, debt counted in dollars suddenly became much heavier. What matters is not only the size of the debt but also who holds it, in what currency, and how much investors trust the state.
The interest snowball
Debt carries interest, and every dollar or euro spent on it is money that cannot go to schools or hospitals. According to the US Congressional Budget Office, in fiscal year 2024 the federal government spent more on interest on its debt than on defence.
Whether debt rises or falls relative to GDP depends on three things: the budget balance excluding interest, the interest rate on the debt, and the growth rate of the economy. If the economy grows faster than the interest rate, debt can “melt” into a growing GDP even with a small deficit. That is how many countries brought their debts down after the Second World War. If the interest rate is higher than growth and the budget has no surplus before interest, debt rolls like a snowball: interest has to be covered with new loans, which carry interest of their own.
Try it below: set the deficit, growth and interest rate and watch what happens to debt over ten years.
Rules and ratings
Many states limit their own borrowing. The 1992 Maastricht Treaty set EU limits: a deficit of up to 3% of GDP and debt of up to 60% of GDP. Poland’s constitution bans borrowing beyond three-fifths of GDP, and in 2009 Germany wrote a debt brake into its constitution that tightly limits the structural deficit (loosened in 2025, notably for defence spending). Supporters of such rules say they protect future generations from paying for today’s promises. Critics reply that rigid limits hold back investment and make it harder to respond to crises; during the pandemic the EU suspended its rules.
The creditworthiness of states is also judged by credit rating agencies. A grade on a scale running down from AAA tells investors how likely it is that a state will not repay. A downgrade usually means the state has to pay higher interest, and falling below so-called investment grade means some funds are not allowed to buy its bonds at all.
When something breaks
When investors lose confidence, they demand ever higher interest until the state can no longer borrow at all. In 2010 Greece lost access to markets and received help from euro-area countries and the IMF in exchange for steep spending cuts and tax rises; in 2012 it went through the largest debt restructuring in history. In 2001 Argentina declared a default at the height of a deep economic and social crisis.
How to avoid such scenarios is one of the oldest debates in politics. Some economists stress that in a crisis the state should borrow and spend to support the economy, and repay in good times. Others warn that the good times are rarely used for repayment, and that high debt leaves a country defenceless for the next crisis. Both sides usually agree on one thing: what matters is not just how much is borrowed, but what it is spent on.
Key terms
- Budget deficit
- The amount by which government spending exceeds income in a given year.
- Public debt
- The total of a state’s unpaid borrowing, the result of all past deficits.
- Debt-to-GDP ratio
- Public debt as a percentage of a country’s yearly output. It makes countries comparable.
- Government bond
- A debt security in which the state promises to repay a loan with interest.
- Credit rating
- An assessment of the risk that a state will not repay its debt. A lower rating usually means higher interest.
- Sovereign default
- When a state fails to pay interest or repay its debt on time.
How it works in Politicus
In Politicus every quarter with a deficit adds to the debt, and the Budget tab shows it as a share of GDP with your country’s thresholds. In Poland the warning comes at 60%, the constitutional limit, and panic at 90%; the US, which markets trust more, has thresholds of 130% and 150%. Crossing the warning line cuts support across all voter groups, and above the panic line the “Debt service” item grows as investors charge a risk premium. Ten points above the panic line, an IMF mission arrives with very painful cuts. The credit rating has nine grades, from AA to D. It is calculated from your average debt over recent quarters, in EU countries a deficit above 3% of GDP caps it at BBB, and the agencies move it step by step. Every downgrade costs prestige. From BB down, debt crises keep coming back and inflation rises. A D rating means the state goes bankrupt and the game ends. In short: credit is easy until nobody wants to give it to you.



